§ 1

Three reasons

1. The prose reads aloud. Paine wrote for the cheap pamphlet press, not the academy. Short sentences, visible rhetorical figures, deliberate pace. Students who freeze on Burke or Madison often catch fire on Paine because the structure is in plain view.
2. The questions still bite. Independence, the rights of the citizen, religion and state, property and inheritance, war and reconciliation -- none of it settled. He states his positions clearly. They invite disagreement.
3. The two-revolutions frame is intact. Paine moved through the inner circles of both the American and French revolutions, and into and out of an English jail-by-warrant. A unit anchored on him opens onto Franklin, Washington, Jefferson, Burke, Wollstonecraft, Robespierre, and the whole transatlantic Enlightenment-into-revolution arc.

§ 2

High school (grades 9–12)

For high-school instructors, the safest starting points are the short pieces with the clearest civic stakes -- suitable for a single class period, with discussion questions that connect to the standard American history and AP English curricula.

• Common Sense, § III "Thoughts on the Present State of American Affairs" (1776) -- about 6,000 words. The single most consequential pamphlet section in American political history. Pairs with the Declaration of Independence and an excerpt from John Dickinson’s Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania.
• The American Crisis, No. I (1776) -- about 2,500 words. The pamphlet Washington ordered read to the troops at Trenton. Excellent for close reading: every sentence does work, and the rhetorical figures are visible.
• African Slavery in America (1775) -- about 2,000 words. Paine’s first major American publication and one of the earliest American calls for abolition by a white writer. Pairs with the preamble he later drafted for Pennsylvania’s Gradual Abolition Act (1780).
• Rights of Man, Part I, the “Miscellaneous Chapter” on hereditary government (1791) -- about 4,000 words. Paine’s direct case against monarchy. Pairs with Burke’s Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790) for compare-and-contrast.

Discussion questions

• What does Paine mean by “hereditary government is in its nature tyranny”? How is that argument different from the case the Declaration of Independence makes against George III specifically?
• Read the opening paragraph of The American Crisis No. I aloud. What rhetorical devices do you hear? What effect do they have on a soldier hearing them at a December campfire?
• Compare Paine’s case against the African slave trade (1775) with the silence of the Declaration of Independence on the same subject (1776). Where do the two documents agree? Where does Paine go further?
• Paine wrote anonymously and refused royalties on Common Sense. How does that publishing choice shape the pamphlet’s reception? Compare with Hamilton’s Federalist essays, also pseudonymous.

§ 3

Undergraduate (American studies, history, English, philosophy)

For an undergraduate seminar, Paine works as a one- to three-week unit anchoring a longer thread on the Atlantic revolutions, the origins of modern liberalism and modern conservatism, or the rhetorical tradition of the political pamphlet.

Suggested readings

• Common Sense (1776) -- the pamphlet that argued America into a country.
• The American Crisis No. I (1776) -- the wartime essay read to the troops at Trenton.
• Rights of Man Parts I-II (1791-92) -- Paine’s reply to Burke and the founding text of modern liberalism.
• The Age of Reason Part I (1794) -- the deistical case for natural religion against revealed religion. Pairs well with Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion for compare-and-contrast.
• Agrarian Justice (1797) -- the original case for what is now called the welfare state. Pairs with the Beveridge Report (1942) and contemporary universal-basic-income proposals.
• The major debates -- Burke vs Paine (1790-92), Watson vs Paine (1796), Paine vs Washington (1796) -- for argument-mapping exercises.

Seminar paper prompts

• Trace the trajectory from Locke’s Second Treatise (1689) through Paine’s Rights of Man Part I (1791). What does Paine keep? What does he simplify or radicalize? Use specific paragraphs from each.
• Paine’s pamphlets were sold at two shillings, read aloud in taverns, reprinted illegally in cheap editions. How does the pamphlet’s material form -- price, distribution, reading context -- shape its prose? Compare a passage from Common Sense with a passage of equal length from a contemporary newspaper or sermon.
• Map the property-and-justice argument across Paine’s career: Common Sense on the “equal rights of nature” (1776), the preamble to the Pennsylvania Abolition Act (1780), Rights of Man Part II on progressive taxation (1792), Agrarian Justice on the citizen’s stake (1797). Where does the position evolve? Where does it stay fixed?
• Use the concept graph as a navigational aid for an “argument-mapping” assignment: have students pick a category (Independence / Rights / Religion / Property) and identify the three most-shared concepts with another category. Why those?

§ 4

Graduate (American studies, religion, history, rhetoric)

At graduate level, the corpus supports thesis-scale projects. The researcher resources page lists every machine-readable surface; the open questions worth pursuing are documented there.

Specific scaffolding

• Critical-edition exercise. Pick one of the major debates (Burke / Watson / Washington). Locate an early printing -- the 1791 first edition of Rights of Man, the 1796 Philadelphia first edition of Letter to George Washington, etc. -- and the Conway-edited text on this site. Collate the two; produce a short variant apparatus. Internet Archive and HathiTrust scans cover the early printings.
• Reception history. Use the Burney Newspaper Collection (British Library) and the early American newspapers in the Library of Congress to locate contemporary press coverage of Common Sense, Rights of Man, or The Age of Reason. Cross-reference with the timeline and revolutionary-cities map to track the geographic spread.
• Stylometric / corpus-linguistic work. The full corpus is available as plain text via /api/downloads.json. Standard NLP pipelines apply. Suggested project: compare Paine’s English-period prose (1772-1787) with his French-period prose (1791-1802) on register, sentence length, and Anglo-Saxon vs Latinate vocabulary.

§ 5

Close-reading: The American Crisis, No. I, opening

Time: 30–40 minutes. Grade: 9 and up. Standards: CCSS RL.9-10.4 (figurative language); RL.11-12.5 (structure of effect).

Procedure

1. Distribute the opening five paragraphs (about 800 words). Read aloud once, all the way through, without comment -- ideally with a student standing at the front of the room.
2. Ask: what kind of writing is this? Who’s the audience? When was it written, and where? (Newark, December 19, 1776, by a man retreating with a beaten army.)
3. Re-read sentence by sentence. After each sentence, ask one student to identify the rhetorical move (parallel structure, question, image, abstraction, etc.).
4. End-of-class question: which single sentence is doing the most work? Defend your choice in three sentences.

§ 6

Argument-mapping: Burke vs Paine

Time: 60–90 minutes. Grade: 11 and up; works for AP, undergrad. Standards: ELA argument analysis; History critical reading.

Procedure

1. Assign one round of the Burke-Paine exchange ahead of class -- a chapter from Burke’s Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790) and the answering chapter from Paine’s Rights of Man Part I (1791). Half the students read Burke; the other half read Paine.
2. In class, each side maps their author’s argument as a 5–7-bullet outline on the board.
3. The two outlines sit side-by-side. The class identifies: (a) where the two authors are talking past each other, (b) where they engage on the same ground, (c) what unstated premises each carries in.
4. Discussion: which writer wins on argument? Which writer wins on rhetoric? Are those the same? (The pamphlet is the founding text of modern liberalism; the Reflections is the founding text of modern conservatism. Both arguments are still in circulation.)

§ 7

Pamphlet-stage exercise: Paine, delivered

Time: 45 minutes prep + one class. Grade: any. Standards: oral interpretation; rhetoric.

Procedure

1. Each student picks a 200–300-word passage from any of the major works (Common Sense, the Crisis, Rights of Man, The Age of Reason, Agrarian Justice).
2. Mark the passage for delivery: pauses, emphasis, breath, pace shifts. Imagine reading aloud to soldiers around a campfire (Crisis), to a coffeehouse audience (Rights of Man), or to a Quaker meeting (Age of Reason) -- the original delivery contexts.
3. One at a time, students stand and deliver their passage. Discussion afterwards: what worked? What did the rhythm reveal that silent reading hid? Why does Paine read so much better aloud than most of his contemporaries?

§ 8

Fair-use guidance

Specific permissions instructors don't need to ask for.

• Photocopying complete works for classroom use.
• Posting any text in a course-management system (Canvas, Blackboard, Moodle).
• Reading aloud, performing, or recording the text for class use or public performance.
• Excerpting in handouts, quizzes, or assignments without page-specific attribution (though academic norms still apply -- see "How to cite" below).

If you adapt this site's editorial layer (timeline events, glossary, concept index, biographical text), that material is licensed CC BY-SA 4.0 and requires attribution plus same-license redistribution. The Conway texts themselves carry no such requirement.

§ 9

How to cite for student work

The cite-dialog on every work page produces APA, MLA, Chicago, and BibTeX strings. For classroom convenience, the canonical short citation is:

Paine, Thomas "Title." The Works of Thomas Paine, Conway Edition, Vol. N, G. P. Putnam's Sons, 1894. Web. filthylittleatheist.com/works/<slug>/.

§ 10

Use it, change it, send corrections

Every page can be linked, embedded, or printed for class. If a passage you cite is later corrected, /works/<slug>/history/ shows the change with a date and a commit hash.

If you're teaching a unit and want a custom reading list, a printable handout, or a corrected text not yet on the site, write to me. Corrections coming back from a class are always welcome.

Start here (five entry-point works) Themed reading plans For researchers Write to me